Students see diluted pledge while abroad
Scott Greene
Issue date: 10/18/07 Section: News
- Page 1 of 3 next >
|
But does the concept of complete immersion have the same affects abroad as it does here in the summer?
"It is clear that students going abroad do not necessarily make gains as significant as those made by students in the Middlebury immersion program," wrote Benjamin Rifkin of the University of Wisconsin-Madison in a 2005 study of Russian language acquisition, specifically referring to Middlebury's Summer Language Schools.
The College's Schools Abroad also require students to abide by the same language pledge as its summer programs, which requires that they speak only the target language while enrolled in the program. Still, members of the College recognize the limits of enforcing the pledge in an abroad setting.
"We can't expect [students] to observe the language pledge at all times in the way that we expect them to do here," said Michael Geisler, vice president for Language Schools, Schools Abroad and Graduate Programs, "because here on campus we can create a somewhat simulated environment where you really don't need to use English."
It is not uncommon for Middlebury students who study a foreign language to first attend one of the College's summer language schools before going abroad. Many students claim that the abroad experience to them is more about learning the culture and expanding their personal horizon, while at summer school the most important thing is language learning.
2008 Woodie Awards
Viewing Comments 1 - 4 of 4
Gabriel
posted 10/18/07 @ 9:47 AM EST
Good article!
I think "a language pledge day off" could be too much but perhaps two hours per week in a meeting with teachers or staff abroad: They could speak in English about frustrations, strategies and targets in their second language learning. (Continued…)
Kim Griffin
posted 10/18/07 @ 10:27 AM EST
As Director of the School in Spain, I have seen over the years that a studentĀ“s commitment to the Language Pledge is an individual issue. Students begin their stay abroad thinking of the Pledge as a requirement without really realizing how truly difficult it is. (Continued…)
pat westwater-jong
posted 10/22/07 @ 8:06 PM EST
I would think a modified pledge where students promise to speak their chosen foreign language as much as possible makes sense. They may be able to go weeks without speaking English - but situations may arise, such as being dinner guests for people who want to speak some English. (Continued…)
W. E. Carl
Waylon Carl
posted 10/22/07 @ 10:44 PM EST
My own commitment to the language pledge never wavered, it simply came to terms with reality. It isn't possible to avoid the use of English entirely because almost all students keep in touch with their families during their time abroad. (Continued…)
Post a Comment